Study Effect of Camphor fumes on the Pulmonary Functions
Mmehibe F O1, Alagwu D N2, Ezekwe A S2, Nwankwo A A1, Alagwu E A2
1Department of Physiology, College of Medicine, Abia State University, PMB 2000 Uturu, Abia State, Nigeria
2Department of Physiology and Biochemistry, College of Medicine ,Imo State University PMB 2000, Owerri, Imo State, Nigeria
Received: 09-Jul-2018 , Accepted: 28-Aug-2018
Keywords: Pulmonary functions, Camphor fumes, Occupation
How To Cite
Effect of occupational exposure to camphor fumes on the pulmonary function was studied using one hundred (100) selected Igbo women working in camphor industry in Aba,Abia State, Sought East Nigeria, exposed to camphor fumes for over 15years (test subjects). They were compared with age, body weight and height marched control who were mostly house wives and civil servants not exposed to any known fumes or air pollutants and with no history of chest infections or spinal cord injury. Lung function indices investigated to include Forced Vital Capacity (FVC), Forced Expiratory Volume per second (FEV1),ration of FEV1/FVC expressed as percentage (FEV1%) and Peak Expiratory Flow Rate (PEFR). The study which lasted for 4 months, was carried out using a Vitalograph Spirometer and Peak Expiratory Flow Meter. Results obtained showed statistically significant reduction in lung function indices (FVC,FEV1 and PEFR) for workers exposed to camphor fumes (test) compared to the control subjects(P<0.001). However,FEV1% in the Test group was 89.1% compared with the control (98.0%).Although both groups appeared normal and within normal values with no statistical difference but in some lung diseases like pulmonary fibrosis and other similar lung conditions,FEV1% may appear normal, yet there is derangement in pulmonary functions. This is not the case in this present study which showed restrictive pattern of lung defect as shown by the significant statistical results. The result of mean values of anthropometric parameters which included age, height, body weight and body mass index obtained showed that the test and control subjects were statistically not significant when compared (P>0.05). It was not possible to determine the effects of environmental factors like carbon dioxide (CO2) carbon monoxide (CO) and other gaseous fumes emitted during the processing period. It is therefore concluded that camphor fumes contributed significantly to the disorder observed in this study.
Smokes and fumes inhalation are reported to have deleterious effect on the pulmonary functions. These smokes and fumes come from cigarette sticks, heated oil, wood combustion, dust, sand mining and gases. They are usually inhaled during the process of heating, mining and manufacturing. Patrick and Femi Pearce (1976)1 reported that anthropometric parameters like age, height, weight and race are important factors that affect pulmonary functions. Atmospheric pollutants like asbestos, sand mining, granite, wood dust have been reported to affect pulmonary function in occupationally exposed workers2-5.
The present study investigated the effect of occupational exposure to camphor fumes on lung functions. Camphor industrial workers in Aba, Abia State, Sought East Nigeria, were studied(test subjects) and compared with age-,weight-and height matched control who were mainly house wives and civil servants not exposed to camphor fumes or any other air pollutants (control subjects). Camphor is a terpenoid substance prepared from wood of Camphor Laurel (Cinnamonum camphora) and other evergreen trees in Asia and other Pacific Countries. Its production involves heating of turpentine oil to a very high temperature using wood and charcoal. The oil vapourizes, freezing at temperature of 175-205 degree Centigrade into a solid camphor materials, packaged into camphor balls and other camphor derivatives and marketed. Its medical and other uses date back to centuries. It is used as ointments, rubs and peppermints. It is also used as antipruritic agent. In industries, it is used for culinary spices, insect repellants and flea killing substance. It is also used as embalmment fluid and preservative. It contains linalool, cineole, nerolidol, satrole and barneol. In Aba, Abia State, Sought East Nigeria, many camphor industries are abound with many people earning their livings from there. Many of the workers have worked there for over 15 years and are exposed everyday to the risk of inhaling unquantified doses of camphor fumes. Although there are reports on the harmful effects of exposure to particulate fumes/smokes of cigarettes6,7, sand mining and asbestos8, Wood dust5, there are paucity of report on the occupational exposure to camphor fumes on the pulmonary function indices of the exposed camphor workers. All the workers that participated in this study denied being aware of potential harmful effect of exposure to camphor fumes and other environmental pollutants associated with heated chaircoal and wood used during the camphor manufacturing period.
2 Materials and Methods
Vitalograph spirometer, weighing scale, non stretchable meter rule, a pair of scissors, Peak Flow Meter, a wooden back chair, a nose clip and a disposable mouth piece.
2.2 Experimental protocol
One hundred (100) Igbo women,aged between 30-47 years, weighing 50-90kg(1,4-1.7mheight),working in camphor industry in Ariari market in Aba, Abia State, Sought East ,Nigeria, exposed to camphor fumes for over 15 years were studied. They constitute the test subjects. The study lasted for 4months.The subjects were educated on the significance of the study and their informed consent was obtained. Inclusion criteria were observed strictly. The subjects were well seated on a back chair. Using vitalograph and Peak Flow meter, they were instructed to forcefully inhale air and exhale it with the nose clipped with nose clip while sitting on a chair quietly with the lips firmly held around the disposable mouth piece such that no air leakage occurs.
Each subject was made to perform the procedure three times with minimum interval of five minutes between each exercise. Lung function indices recorded include FVC, FEV1. FEV1% and PEFR. The test and control subjects were subjected to these procedures. Other measurements and readings taken were weight (kg), height (m), body mass index (BMI, kg/m2) calculated.
Inclusion criteria are:
- Subjects are non smokers
- Subjects are those willing to participate fully and freely
- Subjects had no past medical history of respiratory infections before the study was carried out
- Subjects are all females and Igbos by tribe
Exclusion criteria include:
- Subjects with past history of chest infections, heart surgery and spinal cord injury
- Subjects with physical disability affecting the spine particularly
- Subjects with thoracic cage abnormality
- Subjects unwilling to fully and freely participate till the end of the study
2.3 Statistical analysis:
SPSS model 14 statistical soft ware was used for data entry and analysis. Chi square was used to compare percentages or ratios. Coefficient of correlation r was used to determine the significance between relationships. Unpaired student t test was used to compare two mean values.P< 0.05 is taken to be significant.
Table 1 showed that the mean values of industrial workers exposed to camphor fumes were for FVC=158±0.46L/m as against control=2.49±0.12L/m. This showed significant difference between the test and control subjects (P<0.001).The FEV1 for the test and control groups are 1.41±0.41 and 2.44L/m, respectively. This also showed significant difference between them (P<0.001). FEV1% for the test and control groups were 95.15±5.18% and 98.59±0.58%, respectively. This was not statistically significant, (P>0.05). PEFR for the test was 3.80+-1.30L/s and control was 5.90±0.41L/s. This was statistically significant (P<0.001).
Table 2 showed mean values of anthropometric parameters for the control and the test groups. There was no statistical significant difference between the anthropometric parameters of the control and the test groups (P>0.05).
Deleterious effects of exposure to smokes and fumes of cigarettes and various heated substances on the lung functions have been reported. Osim et al (1992)4 reported derangement of lung functions in sand miners and workers exposed to asbestos. Okwari et al (2005)5 reported decrease in lung function indices in workers exposed to wood dust. Tredaniel et al (1994)6, Wells,(1994)7 reported that cigarette smoke has deleterious effect on the lung functions.
Maduka et al (2009)8 also reported that occupational exposure to local powdered tobacco(snuff) has deleterious effect on pulmonary function. In this study, effect of occupational exposure to camphor fumes on the camphor industrial workers was studied using one hundred selected Igbo women. Results obtained showed reduction in the pulmonary function indices (FVC, FEV1and PEFR) of the industrial workers exposed to camphor fumes compared with the control. FVC for the test group was 1.58± 0.46L/m as against control group 2.49±0.12L/m, FEV1 for the test subjects was 1.41±0.41L/m, FEV1 for the control =2.44±0.10L/m, PEFR for the test and control groups were 3.80±1.30L/s and 5.90±9.41L/s, respectively. FVC, FEV1 and PEFR for the test subjects were statistically reduced significantly when compared with control subjects,(P<0.001).FEV1% for the test and control were 95.18±5.18% and 98.59±0.58%, respectively.
This was not statistically significant when compared. The results obtained in this study showed that the pattern of impaired pulmonary function indices in camphor industrial exposed workers was that of restrictive lung function defect. This finding agreed with those of Osim et al(1992)4, Okwari et al (2005)8 and Maduka et al(2009)8 who worked on sand mining and asbestos, wood dust and tobacco (snuff)related occupational exposures respectively.
Obstructive lung defect was however absent in this study as shown by the normal values of FEV1% in both the test and control groups. Since anthropometric parameters like age, sex, height, race and body weight have been shown to influence lung function indices (FVC, FEV1 and PEFR) as reported by Patrick and Femi Pearce (1976)1, Johannsen and Erasinus (1968)9, Aderele and Oduwole (1983)10, Jaja and Fagbenro (1995)11 these factors were taken into consideration in this study and all were statistically not significant when both the test and control were compared(P>0.05).
It is therefore concluded that camphor fumes caused significant restrictive pattern of lung function defect in camphor Indus trial workers exposed to camphor fumes.
6 Competing interests
Authors have agreed and declared that no competing interests exist.
7 Author’s contributions
MFO and NAA carried out literature review and experimental, EAS, ADN and AEA were responsible for statistical work, calculations and typesetting of data and gained workers concepts. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
- Patrick JM, Femi Pearse A. Reference values for FVC and FEV1 in Nigeria men and women, a graphical summary Niger. Med. J. 1976; 6: 380-385.
- Doll R, Peto J. Effect on health of exposure to asbestos. Health and safety Commission, Her Majesty’s Stationary Office. London. 1985.
- Michael RS, Petty FL. Synopsis of Clinical Pulmonary Disease,3rd ed. London CV Mosby, 1982; 25-27.
- Osim EE, Esim RA, Fossung FE, Archibong EI. Ventilatory function in Nigeria asbestos factory workers. East Afri. Med. J. 1992; 69; 42; 43-46.
- Okwari OO, Antai AB, Owu DU, Peters EJ, Osim EE. Lung function status of wokers exposed to wooddust in timber markets in Calabar, Nigeria. Afr.J. Med. Sci. 2005; 34:141-145.
- Tredaniel J, Ruffeta P, Saracci R, HirSal A. Exposure to environmental tobacco smoke and adult non-neoplastic respiratory disease. Eur. Respir. J. 1994; 7: 173-185.
- Wells AJ. Passive smoking as a cause of heart disease. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 1994; 24: 546-556.
- Maduka SO, Osim EE, Nneli RO, Anyabolu AE. Effect of occupational exposure to local powdered tobacco(snuff) on pulmonary function in Sought East Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of Physiological Sciences. 2009; 24(2):195-202.
- Johannsen ZM, Erasinus LD. Clinical spirometry in normal Bantu. Am. Rev. Respir Dis. 1967; 97: 585-598.
- Aderel WJ, Oduwole O. Peak Expiratory Flow Rate in healthy school children. Nig. J. Paed.1983; 105: 45-55.
- Jaja SI, Fag benro AO. Peak expiratory flow rate in Nigeria school children. Afr.j.Med.Sci. 1995; 24:379-384.